There are a lot of form claimed that they are the Big spear but we believe that this is almost impossible to do the flower spear with a Big spear
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Mon Nov 08, 2010 1:00 pm
From Wu bei lu, the da qiang or big spear was practiced till it can pierce armor. The spear used today does not have such quality, too light, soft and the head is too heavy.
The heavy spear is used today to train power.
Today spear is probably developed upon on dual used spear, one on one dual. But not ideal for battle use, where team is fighting against team. IMHO.
Over
kwong Admin
文章數 : 1510 注冊日期 : 2009-01-25
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Tue Nov 09, 2010 12:33 pm
Overlord wrote:
From Wu bei lu, the da qiang or big spear was practiced till it can pierce armor. The spear used today does not have such quality, too light, soft and the head is too heavy.
The heavy spear is used today to train power.
Today spear is probably developed upon on dual used spear, one on one dual. But not ideal for battle use, where team is fighting against team. IMHO.
Over
hey Andy,
If u tried to use the modern Heavy spear to practice pierce, u will find it is very powerful
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Tue Nov 09, 2010 12:51 pm
Yeah.....but having power is one thing. But remember the story of have all the eggs in one basket. And if the spear body is too soft to support the head, that can cause problem.
Over
kwong Admin
文章數 : 1510 注冊日期 : 2009-01-25
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Tue Nov 09, 2010 12:59 pm
Overlord wrote:
Yeah.....but having power is one thing. But remember the story of have all the eggs in one basket. And if the spear body is too soft to support the head, that can cause problem.
Over
then we need to know what have been used in the past. look at 紀考新書 there is a answer. they used the High density tree to make a pole
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Wed Nov 10, 2010 11:07 pm
There is one interesting movement , i suspect is what is called Ling Mao Bu Shu 靈貓捕鼠, i think in 器王正眼 無隱錄.
Over
Last edited by Overlord on Wed Dec 08, 2010 12:25 pm; edited 2 times in total
tankinbj
文章數 : 46 注冊日期 : 2010-09-06 來自 : Hong Kong
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Wed Dec 08, 2010 3:44 am
I love spear but hard to practice in HK. No enough space for practicing in town.
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Wed Dec 08, 2010 12:18 pm
yeah...is hard...wish there is a solution to that...
Over
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Thu Dec 09, 2010 10:59 pm
This is what i mean by most of us get into weapon sparring too early, not enough foot work, dont know how to use the weapon properly, not enough drilling, not enough speed, not enough basics....
THIS IS REAL DEAL! Nothing fancy, just solid foot work and basics. Enjoy.
Domoarigado gozaiimasu, who ever post this clip.
Over
tankinbj
文章數 : 46 注冊日期 : 2010-09-06 來自 : Hong Kong
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Thu Dec 09, 2010 11:41 pm
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Fri Dec 10, 2010 7:54 am
I doubt there is any chinese spear vs sword clip up to this standard, unfortunatlly no at the moment. Maybe there is, just not on the clips. The tech demoed are movements well recorded in Wu Bei Lu or 器王正眼 無隱錄. Please double check. Called 摩旗 (mo qi shi). That is spear tech. without wrist movement or turning.
Tank, you got to understand, the kendoka in this clip must be way better than the spear person to beat him. Actually, he is. But if you dont think so, means you still got big room to grow.
Infact, He needs to have better understanding of spear than the opponent.
As for the single hand chinese sword, it requires even greater skill to beat the spear. So i hope i dont offend anyone making comments before (about sparring too early). But that is the truth.
In the past, zha is practiced for three years before lang and nan. You get the picture. And shame on me, my zha is still not solid enough. Even the zha in the clip still has room for improvement. What do you guys think?
Have to say this clip make my blood boiled in my vein, fighdo!
Over
kwong Admin
文章數 : 1510 注冊日期 : 2009-01-25
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Sat Dec 11, 2010 1:30 pm
according to the book
Sword VS spear almost equal to sucide. I saw 無隱錄 told me
tankinbj
文章數 : 46 注冊日期 : 2010-09-06 來自 : Hong Kong
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Sat Dec 11, 2010 2:41 pm
OVER兄
Thank you for your introduction of the book "器王正眼 無隱錄". It is my first time hearing it. I checked the introduce of it from web. Very Good! Of course, I still got big room to grow. I am just 1 yr old (in the world of martial). I am glad if you teach me more
haha, I feel your blood that it is so easily boiling up while you are handling the matters about martial. The discussing group about martial is very boring in HK. They are always talking about Wing Chun only...
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Sat Dec 11, 2010 2:53 pm
kwong wrote:
according to the book
Sword VS spear almost equal to sucide. I saw 無隱錄 told me
True. When you are on the same level, sword vs spear is a sucide. But i always wonder how samurai did it and became so famous in the old days. Keep in mind, 無隱錄 may not necessary have the best insight on how sword is used.
For instance, 單刀法選 earlies Jap sword recorded on chinese literature perhaps bit like this...
But we all know this is dame dangerous...if there is no footwork.....
Over
Last edited by Overlord on Sat Dec 11, 2010 3:41 pm; edited 3 times in total
kwong Admin
文章數 : 1510 注冊日期 : 2009-01-25
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Sat Dec 11, 2010 2:57 pm
tankinbj wrote:
OVER兄
Thank you for your introduction of the book "器王正眼 無隱錄". It is my first time hearing it. I checked the introduce of it from web. Very Good! Of course, I still got big room to grow. I am just 1 yr old (in the world of martial). I am glad if you teach me more
haha, I feel your blood that it is so easily boiling up while you are handling the matters about martial. The discussing group about martial is very boring in HK. They are always talking about Wing Chun only...
but it has a lot of wrong word so it is a good collection but is not reliable
Last edited by kwong on Sat Dec 11, 2010 3:01 pm; edited 1 time in total
Overlord Admin
文章數 : 507 注冊日期 : 2009-09-27 來自 : 台灣
Subject: Re: 六合大槍 big Spear Sat Dec 11, 2010 3:00 pm
kwong wrote:
tankinbj wrote:
OVER兄
Thank you for your introduction of the book "器王正眼 無隱錄". It is my first time hearing it. I checked the introduce of it from web. Very Good! Of course, I still got big room to grow. I am just 1 yr old (in the world of martial). I am glad if you teach me more
haha, I feel your blood that it is so easily boiling up while you are handling the matters about martial. The discussing group about martial is very boring in HK. They are always talking about Wing Chun only...